We publish measurements and method.

Nobody needs another ten-tips post about answer engines. What's missing is somebody sampling them on a schedule and printing the numbers with the intervals attached, including the numbers that argue against buying anything from us.

Read the guide

Latest notes

Each one names its sample, its date, and where it could be wrong. That is the whole format.

Field notes4 min read

Asked for alternatives to Profound or Peec AI, four AI engines named the same three tools in 95% of answers

What are the alternatives to Profound and Peec AI? We asked ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews four versions of that question on 16 days. Otterly.AI was named in 235 of 248 answers, and 96 of the 126 names we counted came from a single engine.

Read the note
Field notes4 min read

After two follow-up questions, AI answers kept 22% of the companies they named first

Does AI still recommend you after a buyer asks a follow-up? In 180 three-question conversations, a third of the opening answers named no company at all, and only 168 of the 753 companies named first were still there by the third answer.

Field notes4 min read

53% of the requests calling themselves GPTBot, ClaudeBot or PerplexityBot on six websites came from somewhere else

Are the AI crawler visits in your logs real? On six websites, 33,964 of 64,222 requests that named an OpenAI, Anthropic or Perplexity bot came from addresses those companies don't list. Most of the impostors claimed several companies' bots at once.

Field notes4 min read

Naming a competitor didn't stop AI describing the wrong company. Naming the category did, in 96 of 96 answers

How do you stop AI confusing your brand with another company? We tested three ways of asking about the same brand. Putting a competitor's name in the question didn't help: 5.1% of answers described a different company, against 4.0% for the bare name. Putting the category in the question did.

Method4 min read

An offer shown only to AI bots reached buyers 370 times. Here is the honest version of that test

A thread with over 600,000 views described Ramp placing an offer on about 50 pages that only AI bots could see, then counting how often AI assistants passed it on. The lessons are real. The method, words shown to bots and not to people, is the part we would not copy. Here is the same test done in the open.

Field notes4 min read

Real searches named the brand in 5.2% of AI answers. Questions written from its site: 7.7%

Which questions should you track to measure your brand in ChatGPT? We split 1,235 tracked questions into real Google searches and questions written from the brand's own website. The written ones named the brand about half as often again, and for 46 of 61 brands.

Field notes4 min read

AI engines cited a broken page on the websites of 18% of brands

Does ChatGPT send people to broken pages on your website? We took every page on a brand's own site that four AI engines cited over five weeks and loaded each one. Most worked. The ones that didn't were mostly pages the brand had moved or deleted, not links the engine made up.

Field notes4 min read

The typical brand's competitor list missed 4 of the 10 companies AI named most

Who does ChatGPT recommend when it doesn't recommend you? Most teams answer with the competitor list they already have. We checked those lists against 31,561 answers from four AI engines. The leader was almost always on the list. A lot of the rest wasn't.

Field notes4 min read

Half of AI answers to "how much does it cost" named no company at all

Should you put your prices on your website so ChatGPT can quote them? We read 828 answers from four AI engines to questions about what something costs. Nearly all gave a number, half named nobody, and the companies that were named often had their own pricing page cited.

Field notes4 min read

AI engines cited a brand's homepage more than any page it owns. The pricing page got 1%.

When ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity or Google AI Overviews cite your website, which page do they open? We sorted every citation of 200 brands' own sites over a month. The homepage led. Asked whether a brand is legit, engines read its terms and privacy pages.

Field notes4 min read

Sites outside the top million were named in 3% of AI answers, mostly on three questions each

We ranked 139 brand websites by traffic and counted how often four AI engines named them in 25,504 answers. The biggest sites were named in half. The 108 sites outside the top million were named in 3%, and most of that came from a few narrow questions.

Field notes4 min read

AI answers to buyer questions named five brands. Perplexity named three.

A buyer who asks an engine for options gets a short list. We counted the names in 26,607 answers from four engines. Three engines named five. Perplexity named three, and 41% of its answers named three or fewer.

Field notes4 min read

One in 20 AI answers about a brand described a different company

A buyer who already knows your name types it into the question. We read who the answer was about. In 5,811 answers from four engines, 372 described a different company, and another 771 couldn't tell which company was meant.

Field notes4 min read

AI Overviews cited 5% of the Reddit threads in Google's forum box

Google's Discussions and forums box looks like a shortlist of the threads that matter for a question. We checked it against the AI Overview on the same page. The Overview cited 48 of the 955 Reddit threads the box showed, and most cited threads weren't on page one at all.

Field notes4 min read

The No. 1 Google result was cited in 31% of AI Overviews for buyer questions

Google's AI Overview and its ten blue links come from the same search, so we could check each cited page against the results underneath it. For 4,722 buyer questions, the No. 1 result made it into the Overview's sources less than a third of the time.

Field notes4 min read

Brands with a Wikipedia page were named in 52% of AI answers. The page was cited in 2% of them.

Brands with a Wikipedia article get named far more often in AI answers. We checked whether the engines were reading the article when they did. In 1,423 answers that named one of these brands, its own Wikipedia page was cited 27 times, and ChatGPT cited it once.

Field notes4 min read

Press release wires were 272 of 201,185 AI citations, and none were the tracked brand's

Press release services now sell distribution as a way into AI answers. We checked every page that ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews cited in 18,858 answers to buyer questions. Wire services got 272 of 201,185 citations. Not one was a release from the brand being tracked.

Field notes4 min read

How-to questions named the brand a third as often as best-of questions

Most advice on choosing prompts to track says to mix problem questions with category questions. We sorted 18,618 answers from ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews by the shape of the question. How-to questions named the brand about a third as often, on every engine, and mostly named nobody at all.

Field notes4 min read

62% of the best-of lists AI engines cited had 2026 in the title, and last year's lists still got in

Every content guide says to put the current year in your title so AI engines treat the page as fresh. We read the year off 32,719 citations of best-of lists in 18,258 buyer answers from ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews. The year turned out to be the norm, not an edge, and the engine's own search mattered more than the page.

Field notes4 min read

AI engines cited vendors' own best-of lists and left the vendor out 38% of the time

Plenty of software companies publish a "best tools for X" list with themselves on top, hoping AI engines will cite it. We looked at 17,651 buyer answers from four engines and asked the question citation counts skip: when the engine cited the vendor's own list, did the answer name the vendor?

Field notes4 min read

Only 22% of the sites the ChatGPT API cited showed up in ChatGPT itself

Some AI visibility tools ask ChatGPT through OpenAI's API. Others read chatgpt.com the way a visitor sees it. We had both answers for the same 172 buyer questions, a day apart, and a baseline of chatgpt.com answering itself a day apart. The brand rate held. The sources didn't.

Field notes4 min read

GPT-6 made ChatGPT's answers 40% longer and named the same brands

ChatGPT's free tier moved to GPT-6 on October 8. We had the same 188 buyer questions on both sides of the switch, for 16 brands, plus the same questions on Claude, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews as a control. Whether ChatGPT named the brand barely moved. Almost everything else about the answer did.

Method5 min read

7 of 72 brand sites hid a key page from AI crawlers that skip JavaScript

ChatGPT's page reader, Claude and Perplexity read the HTML your server sends and never run your scripts. We compared that view with a browser's on 211 key pages across 72 brand sites. Most came through whole. Seven sites lost a headline, a pricing table or every case study, and half the scary scores turned out to be cookie banners.

Method4 min read

One AI answer in 13 that named the brand got a fact about it wrong

A mention rate counts an answer as a win the moment it names you. We checked what 2,137 of those answers on ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews actually said about 80 brands. Here's what was wrong, which answers got it wrong, and what to open behind your own number.

Method4 min read

Rewording a buyer question moved AI answers more than asking it again

We compared two things for 96 brands on ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews: asking the same buyer question again, and asking it a different way on the same day. The wording mattered far more. Here's what that means for which phrasings you test.

Method4 min read

Half the daily changes in AI answers reversed the next day

We asked the same 40 buyer questions on ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews every day for seven to nine days. About one name in five dropped out of an answer overnight, and nearly half of those changes reversed the next day. Here's what that means for choosing between a daily and a weekly scan.

Method4 min read

ChatGPT named 89% of brands it typed into its first search

ChatGPT doesn't search for the buyer's question. It writes its own query, and in 2,502 logged-out answers we sampled, that query often already held brand names nobody had typed. The brands it searched for were named 89% of the time. Here's what that means for getting recommended, and how to check which side of the line you're on.

Method4 min read

The AI leader fell from 59% to 40% when no brand was named

We benchmarked our own brand against the AI visibility tool that engines name most often: 25 buyer questions, four engines, 220 answers. Nine of the questions named a tool, and those nine did a lot of the leader's work for it. Here's how to set up the comparison so the gap you report is the real one.

Method4 min read

ChatGPT called one tool both GEO and AEO on the same day

We asked ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews 25 questions about tools that track brands in AI answers. None of the questions said AEO or GEO. The answers used GEO in 64 of 180 and AEO in 31, often for the same vendor. Here's where the two terms came from, why the label won't help you choose, and the split that will.

Method4 min read

Same AI mention rate, named first 38 times vs 15

Most AI visibility tools lead with a mention rate. In one category we track, two companies were each named in 70 of 160 answers from ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews. One was named first 38 times, the other 15. A mention rate can't see that. Here's what a tool should measure before you pay for it, and the questions that tell you whether it does.

Playbook4 min read

Engines cited 129 sites that publish llms.txt 6,343 times. Once, it was the file

llms.txt is the most recommended fix in AI search, and the least checked. We took the 300 domains that ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews cited most in our samples and fetched each one's file. 129 publish one. Those 129 sites were cited 6,343 times, and one citation pointed at the file. Eight of the ten most cited sites have none. Here's what the file is for, and what to spend the hour on instead.

Method4 min read

Our tracker missed Google's AI Overview on 96% of searches. One setting fixed it

From August 22 to September 7 our sampler recorded no Google AI Overview for 193 of 201 searches. Google had shown one almost every time. The Overviews load after the page, and our data vendor only returns them if you ask. On the same 36 questions after the fix, 3 of 487 searches came back empty. Here's what that means for any number a tracker gives you about Google.

Playbook4 min read

Seven universal sites took 5% of citations in 15 categories

Ask which sites to get mentioned on and you'll get the same list: Reddit, Wikipedia, YouTube, LinkedIn. Those lists are real, and they're built from every topic people ask about. We counted the citations behind buyer questions in 15 categories instead. The universal sites barely registered. Almost everything cited belonged to one category alone.

Field notes4 min read

When one AI engine named the brand, all four did 32% of the time

Most AI visibility reports give you one number, or one number per engine that looks about the same. We put the same unbranded questions to ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity and Claude on the same day and compared the answers question by question. The engines disagreed with each other more than any one of them disagreed with itself the next day.

Playbook4 min read

Competitor websites took 16% of the AI citations we counted. The brand's own site took 0.87%.

Half the advice says publish depth on your own domain and the engines will find it. The other half says your own domain barely matters. We counted every citation in 1,205 answers to unbranded buyer questions. Vendor websites were the biggest single block of sources, so the channel plainly works. They were almost never the website of the brand doing the asking.

Playbook4 min read

Software directories are 1.8% of AI citations, and the cited page is almost never yours

The standard advice is to claim your G2 and Capterra profiles and fill in every field, because review profiles are where AI answers come from. We counted every citation in 1,099 sampled answers. Directories took 1.8% of them, and the page an engine took was usually a category ranking or a competitor's alternatives list. The brand's own profile came up 8 times out of 9,198.

Playbook4 min read

ChatGPT named the brand 78% of the time it searched, and 6% when it didn't

You ask ChatGPT who the best tools in your category are, your competitors come back, and you don't. The standard explanation is that your content isn't authoritative enough. In our sample the likelier explanation was that the model never looked anything up. It answered from memory, and when it did that it named the brand 6% of the time instead of 78%.

Playbook4 min read

59% of the YouTube links in AI Overviews jumped to a timestamp

Every guide says to start a YouTube channel, because Google favors its own platform. YouTube was indeed the most cited domain in our sample, at 10.4% of Google AI Overview citations and 0.7% of ChatGPT's. Then we looked at the links themselves. Most of them skipped to a specific second inside the video, usually inside the first two minutes, and 11 of 533 were on the channel of the brand we were measuring.

Playbook4 min read

Reddit is 3% of AI citations, and every one is a single thread

Every guide to getting recommended by ChatGPT says to get on Reddit. We counted what two engines actually cited over five weeks. Reddit sat near the top of the domain list and still carried about 3% of the links. All 183 of them pointed at a single thread, and the two engines almost never picked the same one. That changes what a brand should do there.

Playbook4 min read

Thirty days can change what ChatGPT looks up, not what it remembers

You asked ChatGPT for the best tools in your category and it named five companies that aren't you. Before you publish anything, know which half of the answer a new page can reach. The model's memory was frozen months ago. The lookup half reads the web today, and only when the engine decides to search. Here's how we'd spend the first thirty days, and why we wouldn't grade new pages at the end of them.

Playbook4 min read

Fix the line a roundup already wrote about you

Every guide to AI visibility tells you to get named in more roundups. Nobody tells you that the roundups already naming you are often wrong about your price, your plan and who you're for, and that the model repeats their sentence instead of your homepage. Zapier publishes its selection criteria, its testing method and a form, and the form's one firm commitment is to fix incorrect information. That's the cheapest move on the board.

Method4 min read

Your error bars overlap and the 12 point drop is real

Your visibility went from 42% to 30% and the error bars still touch, so nothing fired. Two 95% intervals drawn from identical populations overlap more than 99% of the time, which makes the overlap check roughly a 1% test instead of the 5% you wanted. On the same 200 prompts a proper test gives p = 0.012, and comparing the prompts that actually flipped gives p = 0.00006. Here is the arithmetic, including what our own alert gate gets wrong.

Method4 min read

Every AI visibility number you have is a turn-one number

Every answer-engine tool, ours included, runs each prompt in a fresh chat and reports who got named. Buyers do not stop at one question. In a 200,000 conversation experiment across fifteen models, delivering the same request over two or more turns cut performance by 39% and more than doubled the gap between the best and worst run. The shortlist at turn two is a different measurement, and nobody is taking it.

Method4 min read

The known brand wins every time, until a competitor is a tenth of a star better

A June 2026 study put three models in front of ten products where only the brand name differed. The known brand won every single trial. Then the researchers gave an unknown competitor the smallest advantage they could measure, and the monopoly collapsed in one step. Once any real difference exists, brand identity explains 1.2% of what gets ranked first.

Method5 min read

Mentions hold still. Sentiment flips 6.7 times more often.

Whether an engine names you on a category question turns out to be close to a settled fact: 77.5% of tracked cells were strictly always or never mentioned. What the answer says about you is the part that moves, flipping on nearly half the cells that had anything to report. Most dashboards lead with the stable number and set alerts on it.

Method5 min read

Ask for the best software and 73% of the cited sources are third-party sites

An AI answer isn't a verdict on your page. It's a set of roughly eight sources, and on a software question about three quarters of them belong to reviewers and comparison sites. Co-citation, a measure defined in 1973, is the useful lens: two documents become neighbors because somebody else kept reaching for both. You don't pick who you appear next to, and that company shapes how a buyer reads you.

Method5 min read

Zero citations doesn't mean the model didn't use your page

The link chips under an AI answer feel like a receipt. They are closer to a caption: text the model produced about its own retrieval, after the fact. The Tow Center handed eight AI search tools an exact paragraph and asked who published it, and the tools got it wrong more than 60% of the time. The gap between what an engine retrieved and what it credited is where a lot of brand visibility quietly goes missing.

Method5 min read

You asked once and the model named you. The honest reading is 21% to 100%.

Someone types the category question into ChatGPT, sees the brand in the answer, and screenshots it for the channel. That screenshot is one Bernoulli trial. Put a 95% Wilson interval on it and the range that stays consistent with what you saw runs from 20.7% all the way to 100%. The engines are non-deterministic by design, and most of what gets reported as a change in AI visibility is a sample too small to have a finding in it.

Method5 min read

Google's AI Mode turns one question into a dozen searches. You track one of them.

Google has written down how AI Mode works, and it is not a ranked list. One question is broken into subtopics and answered by a set of searches the engine writes itself. A Google engineering director puts the everyday case at a dozen. If you are tracking one head term, you are watching the only question in the set that you chose.

Method5 min read

Blocking GPTBot doesn't remove you from ChatGPT. Blocking OAI-SearchBot does.

There's a robots.txt line going around that blocks GPTBot, and a lot of people added it thinking they'd made a decision about ChatGPT. They made a different one. Here's which agent actually gates which answer, straight from each engine's own docs, and how to check your site in an afternoon.

Field notes4 min read

When an AI summary appears, clicks fall from 15% to 8%

Pew watched 900 people search for a month. When an AI summary showed up, people clicked a result 8% of the time instead of 15%, and clicked a source inside the summary 1% of the time. Here is what that does to a brand, and where the number could be wrong.

Three findings we keep coming back to

All three are our own live measurements, in the category we tested. None of them are market forecasts, because we can't source one we'd trust.

44%

Listicles were 44% of what ChatGPT cited for “best X” in the category we tested. Review sites 24%, vendor pages 18%, editorial 14%. Most of those listicles take submissions, so they're the cheapest gap in the whole report to close. There's a post in that, and no secret.

0

No engine we track documents llms.txt as a ranking signal. It's the most-recommended item in this space. It's cheap to publish, and we publish one, but it won't get you named on its own. We'll keep saying so, including when it costs us a sale.

5-7

The same five to seven names hold across almost every phrasing. If the list reshuffled at random it wouldn't be worth winning. It doesn't. It holds, which is why it's worth getting into and worth defending once you're there.

Every post names its sample, its date, and where it could be wrong. That's the whole format.

Ask the same question tomorrow and 9 to 27% of the names change.

Perplexity moved most at 27% day over day, Claude least at 9%, in our own sampling. An article about answer engines goes stale much faster than an article about search ever did. That's why we'd sooner publish a running measurement than a take.

  • Every figure carries its interval, a 95% Wilson score interval, so we can't sell you a wobble as progress
  • If a post quotes a number, it quotes the day we sampled it
  • When a finding stops holding, we say it stopped holding
Day-over-day churn
Perplexity27%
ChatGPT18%
AI Overviews12%
Claude9%

Average change in which brands get named, same question, one day apart. Proofsource sampling.

On the writing list

What we are measuring and writing up next.

One answer is not a measurement

Why a single run carries an interval, and what a Wilson interval actually rules out.

Reading a citation like a map

The sources behind an answer tell you which pages you have to be on. We'll show the working.

Presence, position, framing

Being named, being named first, and being named well are three different measurements.

Your own numbers beat our best post.

The shortlist in your category is being written right now, whether anyone reads this page or not. A free trial, 25 questions on four engines today, tells you if your name is in it.

100 answers. 25 Prompts/Question. Top AI engines. Free.ChatGPTPerplexityClaudeGoogle AI OverviewsGoogle AI ModeGeminiMicrosoft CopilotGrokDeepSeekMeta AI