We read 248 answers to four alternatives questions
What are the alternatives to Profound and Peec AI? Plenty of pages answer that, and most are written by a company in the category. SE Ranking's guide to Profound alternatives lists eight tools with SE Ranking first. Frase's guide to Peec AI alternatives lists seven with Frase first. We publish comparison pages too. So we asked a different question: what do the AI engines tell a buyer who asks?
Proofsource tracks its own brand's buyer questions every day. Four of them ask for alternatives: three to Peec AI (for daily monitoring across engines, for tracking prompt variations, for tracking competitors) and one to Profound (for small businesses). Each ran on ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews, asked from the US, on 16 days between October 4 and November 16, 2026. That's 248 answers. We counted every company each one named.
Three tools were named in about 95% of the answers
Otterly.AI was named in 235 of the 248 answers: 94.8% (91.2% to 96.9%). Profound was named in 182 of the 188 answers to the Peec AI questions (96.8%). Peec AI was named in 57 of the 60 answers to the Profound question (95.0%). Ask for an alternative to either one, and the other is almost always on the list.
All three were named on every engine on every day we sampled. If you're shopping in this category, you'll hear these three names whichever engine you ask.
Below the top three, the engine decided the list
The next names were Semrush in 59.3% of answers, Scrunch in 51.6%, AthenaHQ in 46.8%, Ahrefs in 44.0% and Rankscale in 38.7%. Those averages hide big gaps between engines.
ChatGPT named AthenaHQ in 53 of its 62 answers. Google AI Overviews named it in 5. ChatGPT named Rankscale in 43 of 62, AI Overviews in 3. Claude named Writesonic in 31 of 62, ChatGPT in 3.
Across all the answers we counted 126 different names, including tools mentioned in passing such as Google Search Console. 96 of them (76.2%) appeared on one engine and no other. AI Overviews in particular brought in newer, smaller tools that the other three engines didn't name in our sample.
Saying who you are moved the list too
The buyer's own words mattered. HubSpot was named in 16 of the 60 answers to the small business question (26.7%) and in 14 of the 188 answers to the other three (7.4%). The Peec AI questions, which asked about monitoring and competitors, brought Scrunch into 117 of 188 answers and Semrush into 112.
Same category, same week, different shortlist. The question a buyer types is part of the answer they get.
What we'd do if we were choosing
- Start with the names every engine agrees on, then add the ones your own engine brings up. A ChatGPT user hears about AthenaHQ and Rankscale far more often than someone reading AI Overviews.
- Ask with your situation in it: team size, budget, the engines you care about. The list changes when you do.
- Treat prices in AI answers as leads. Several answers quoted a monthly price next to each name, sourced to roundups. Check the vendor's own pricing page.
- Run a trial on your own questions. A place on an AI shortlist says a tool is well known. Fit is something you test.
Where Proofsource came out
We sell a tool in this category, so here is our own line. Proofsource was named in 6 of the 248 answers (2.4%), all on Claude and all on the daily monitoring question. Claude and ChatGPT cited our Peec AI comparison page as a source in 22 answers, and most of those didn't name us. We aren't on this shortlist yet.
How Proofsource measures it
Proofsource asks your buyer questions on each engine you track, every day, and records every company each answer names. You can see who is named next to you, on which engine and for which question.
Where this could be wrong
Four questions, all written by us, in English, asked from the US. A buyer in another country, or one who words it differently, may get a different list.
16 days, and only two of them before November 3. Shortlists in a young category can move as tools launch and get written about.
We're a vendor here. We've reported every count as we found it, including our own, and we haven't described any tool's strengths or weaknesses.
Names were extracted from the answers by a model and grouped by company by hand: Semrush and its AI Visibility Toolkit count as Semrush, Ahrefs and Brand Radar as Ahrefs. Answers from the same day share sources, so they aren't independent and the intervals are approximate. Gemini isn't in this sample.