Proofsource vs Nightwatch

Nightwatch is a rank tracker that now reads AI answers too: six AI platforms, Claude included, on every plan next to Google, Bing and YouTube rankings. Proofsource is built around buyer questions alone, with an interval on every share and a drafted fix for each gap.

See every comparison
100 answers. 25 Prompts/Question. Top AI engines. Free. No card · no sales call

Proofsource and Nightwatch in five facts

Price

Proofsource
Free trial, then monthly credits from $9 a month for 500 credits
Nightwatch
Starter €79 a month (500 keywords, 50 AI prompts), Professional €159 (150 prompts), Agency €399 (500 prompts); Enterprise custom[1]

Free trial

Proofsource
One free scan, 4 engines, no card
Nightwatch
14 days on every plan, no credit card[1]

AI engines covered

Proofsource
4 on the trial, up to 4 on a paid plan
Nightwatch
ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Mode and Google AI Overviews on every plan[1]

How often answers are re-read

Proofsource
Daily, weekly or monthly, you choose
Nightwatch
Daily, with on-demand checks[1][2]

Seats

Proofsource
Unlimited team members
Nightwatch
Unlimited seats on every plan; no per-seat fees[1]

What Nightwatch is, and who it is for

Rank tracking first, AI alongside. Nightwatch tracks daily positions on Google, YouTube, Bing, Yahoo, DuckDuckGo and Google Maps, and every plan adds AI prompts on six AI platforms. Plans are priced by keywords tracked, with unlimited seats and the full toolkit on each.[1]

Citation Intelligence. Its featured AI tool shows which URLs ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini cite, scores how strongly each source influences answers, and links ranking changes to changes in AI citations.[2][3]

Locations at zip-code depth. Nightwatch says it tracks from 107,000+ locations down to the zip code in 190+ countries and 170+ languages, keeps every rank check since 2012 with the raw results page behind it, and serves 10,000+ SEO teams.[3]

Proofsource is an AI intelligence platform that shows which buyer questions name your brand in ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews, who gets named instead, and exactly what to fix.

Proofsource and Nightwatch, fact by fact

Each Nightwatch cell links to the page it came from. Where Nightwatch does not publish a detail, the cell says so instead of guessing.

QuestionProofsourceNightwatch
PriceFree trial, then monthly credits from $9 a month for 500 credits at self-serve checkout: 1 credit per checked answer, and keeping a brand up to date uses daily (1,000 credits a brand a month) or weekly (350 credits). Unused credits roll overStarter €79 a month (500 keywords, 50 AI prompts), Professional €159 (150 prompts), Agency €399 (500 prompts); Enterprise custom[1]
Free trial100 answers. 25 Prompts/Question. Top AI engines. Free. No card, no sales call14 days on every plan, no credit card[1]
AI engines coveredChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews on the trial. Paid plans pick from those 4, each answer paid in credits; Google AI Mode, Gemini, Microsoft Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek and Meta AI are enabled on a callChatGPTClaudeGeminiPerplexityGoogle AI ModeGoogle AI OverviewsChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Mode and Google AI Overviews on every plan[1]
How often answers are re-readDaily or weekly, chosen per plan; daily is one answer per question per engine per UTC day. The trial reads every engine once, at signupDaily, with on-demand checks[1][2]
SeatsUnlimited team members on every plan. The agency account is free forever and self-serve, with scoped members and Client Viewer logins; each client uses creditsUnlimited seats on every plan; no per-seat fees[1]
How a number is measuredA 95% Wilson interval on every percentage; alerts wait until a change clears itVisibility, average position in list answers, share of voice and sentiment per prompt, plus citation analysis[2]
What it does about a gapEach gap names the pages the engine cited instead, with a draft fix held for your approvalContent Studio, Prompt Research, Site Audit and an SEO Agent on every plan[1]

Where each shines

Both tools are built well for different teams. Each point is a strength, read from that vendor's own pages.

Where Nightwatch shines

  • Search rankings and AI answers in one login. If you already track keywords, Nightwatch keeps daily Google, Bing and YouTube positions beside AI visibility, with Looker Studio, an API and white-label reports from Professional.[1]
  • Claude and AI Mode on the entry plan. All six AI platforms come on every tier; plans differ in volume, not engines.[1]
  • Ranking changes tied to citations. Citation Intelligence joins the rank tracker's data with AI citations, so a drop in AI visibility can be traced to a specific URL and keyword.[3]

Where Proofsource shines

  • Questions, not keywords. Proofsource is built around the buyer questions that decide a shortlist: it reads ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews on the trial and by default on every plan; Google AI Mode, Gemini, Microsoft Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek and Meta AI are enabled on a call, and shows who is named instead of you on each.
  • An interval on every share. Every Proofsource percentage carries a 95% Wilson interval, and alerts wait until a change clears it, so a one-day swing is not reported as a trend.
  • A drafted fix per gap. Each gap names the pages the engines cited instead, with a draft held for your approval. Proofsource starts free, then monthly credits from $9 a month for 500 credits, with unlimited team members.

Proofsource or Nightwatch: the fair verdict

Nightwatch is the stronger fit for an SEO team that lives in rank tracking and wants AI visibility, local positions and citation data in the same tool, Claude included.

Proofsource is the stronger fit for a team that wants the AI answer itself as the unit of work: which buyer questions name you, how sure the number is, and which page to change first.

Teams with a large keyword program can run both; the data does not overlap much.

Choose Nightwatch if you want

  • Search rankings and AI answers in one login
  • Claude and AI Mode on the entry plan
  • Ranking changes tied to citations

Choose Proofsource if you want

  • Questions, not keywords
  • An interval on every share
  • A drafted fix per gap

Already using Nightwatch?

You do not have to choose on day one. Here is how teams run Proofsource beside Nightwatch and decide on their own data.

  1. Keep Nightwatch running

    Nothing about trying Proofsource needs you to stop Nightwatch. Your history and reports there stay where they are.

  2. Bring your questions across

    Export or copy the prompts you track in Nightwatch and add them as buyer questions in Proofsource, so both tools ask the same things.

  3. Run both side by side

    Read the two for the same days on your own domain. Where the numbers differ, Proofsource shows the answers and the pages each engine cited, so you can see why.

  4. Keep what serves your team

    Many teams keep one tool for reporting and another for fixes. Pick on your own evidence, not on a comparison page.

Proofsource or Nightwatch: what buyers ask

How much does Nightwatch cost?

Its pricing page lists Starter at €79 a month with 500 keywords and 50 AI prompts, Professional at €159 and Agency at €399, with Enterprise priced to volume and a 14-day free trial on every plan. Proofsource starts free, then monthly credits from $9 a month for 500 credits.

Which AI engines does Nightwatch track?

ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Mode and Google AI Overviews on every plan. Proofsource reads ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews on the trial and by default on every plan; Google AI Mode, Gemini, Microsoft Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek and Meta AI are enabled on a call.

Is Nightwatch an AI visibility tool or a rank tracker?

Both. Its core is daily rank tracking across search engines, and every plan adds AI prompts tracked daily with visibility, position, share of voice and sentiment.

How often does Nightwatch update AI visibility?

Daily, alongside rank tracking, with on-demand checks. Proofsource re-reads on the cadence you pick (daily or weekly) and marks whether each change is outside its interval.

Where each fact about Nightwatch comes from

  1. Nightwatch pricing and plan comparison, read Oct 15, 2026.
  2. Nightwatch AI tracking, read Oct 15, 2026.
  3. Nightwatch homepage, read Oct 15, 2026.

Vendors change their pages. If a Nightwatch fact here no longer matches their site, tell us through the contact page and we will correct it.

Every comparison we have written

Your own trial settles this faster than any comparison page.

100 answers. 25 Prompts/Question. Top AI engines. Free. No card, and the report is about your domain: which buyer questions name you, who gets named instead, and what to fix.

100 answers. 25 Prompts/Question. Top AI engines. Free.ChatGPTPerplexityClaudeGoogle AI OverviewsGoogle AI ModeGeminiMicrosoft CopilotGrokDeepSeekMeta AI