Proofsource vs Indexly
Indexly bundles daily AI visibility tracking on three models of your choice with SEO indexing, site audits and content and social agents. Proofsource measures one thing closely: what ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews say about you, with an interval on every figure.
Proofsource and Indexly in five facts
Price
- Proofsource
- Free trial, then monthly credits from $9 a month for 500 credits
- Indexly
- Starter $99, Growth $299, Scale $499 a month billed monthly; 17% off annually[1]
Free trial
- Proofsource
- One free scan, 4 engines, no card
AI engines covered
- Proofsource
- 4 on the trial, up to 4 on a paid plan
- Indexly
- Any 3 AI models on the AI Visibility plan, from ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Grok, Claude and Google AI Overviews[1]
How often answers are re-read
- Proofsource
- Daily, weekly or monthly, you choose
- Indexly
- Tracked daily[1]
Seats
- Proofsource
- Unlimited team members
- Indexly
- Team management on Growth and Scale, not on Starter[1]
What Indexly is, and who it is for
Track, optimize and measure in one place. Indexly tracks how AI engines cite your brand, improves visibility through content agents, Reddit presence and LinkedIn authority, and measures the resulting SEO and AI traffic in one dashboard.[2]
For marketing teams, brands and agencies. Its plans pair prompt tracking with indexing submissions, website audits and monthly articles, and an agency bundle manages several client projects under one bill.[1]
Proofsource is an AI intelligence platform that shows which buyer questions name your brand in ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews, who gets named instead, and exactly what to fix.
What you keep, what Proofsource adds
Move from Indexly without losing your questions, and add what Proofsource is built to do.
| What you keep, what you gain | What you get with Proofsource | Keep or adds |
|---|---|---|
| Your questions | Every Indexly prompt imported, topics kept | Keep |
| Your history | Your past numbers stay with you as an export; Proofsource starts measuring on day one | Keep |
| 10 AI engines | ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews from the first scan, and up to 10 engines on request. Engines and models | Adds |
| Fixes with a preview | Each gap comes with a drafted fix you preview and approve before anything changes. Fix it | Adds |
| New pages and revamps | Writes new pages and revamps existing ones on your own site, in your site's own style. Pages | Adds |
| 80+ integrations | Connects to 80+ tools: your CMS, host, analytics, tickets, chat and reports. Integrations | Adds |
| Proof against controls | Control questions measure normal answer noise, so a change smaller than that is never called a win. Drift tracking | Adds |
| A 95% interval on every figure | Every percentage carries a 95% interval, and alerts wait until a change clears it. Methodology | Adds |
| Lead search and outreach | Finds businesses AI leaves out, with a checked email per lead, and drafts the pitch you send. Lead finder | Adds |
| Agency workspaces and white-label reports | One workspace per agency with every client inside, and reports under your own brand. White-label reports | Adds |
| Calendar and booking | Connects your mailbox and calendar so prospects book a call straight from a pitch. Outreach setup | Adds |
| Prices on the page | Every plan's price is on the pricing page, with a free trial and no sales call to start. Pricing | Adds |
| Your data out, any time | Full history as CSV or JSON, any date range, and a REST API. Export | Adds |
Where each shines
Both tools are built well for different teams. Each point is a strength, read from that vendor's own pages.
Where Indexly shines
- SEO and AI search in one subscription. Indexly adds indexing submissions, SEO and AI readiness audits, backlink intelligence and article writing to its AI tracking on one self-serve bill. Proofsource runs site readiness audits and drafts content in the product, and on Managed its team writes and publishes the articles for you.[1]
- Several countries on the entry plan. The AI Visibility plan tracks 100 prompts across 2 sites and 2 countries of your choice.[1]
- Social and forum agents. Its social agents publish posts and threads, and its Reddit and LinkedIn work targets the off-site sources AI answers lean on.[2]
Where Proofsource shines
- All four main engines by default. Proofsource asks ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews on the trial and by default on every plan, where Indexly's AI Visibility plan tracks the 3 models you pick.
- Intervals before alerts. Every Proofsource rate carries a 95% Wilson interval, and an alert waits until a change clears it.
- A trial you can run alone. 100 answers. 25 Prompts/Question. Top AI engines. Free. No card, no sales call.
Proofsource or Indexly: the fair verdict
If you want one tool for SEO indexing, audits and content production as well as AI tracking, Indexly covers more ground for one monthly price.
If you need to trust the AI visibility number itself, Proofsource is the stronger pick: four engines by default, an interval on every figure, and a draft fix built from the pages that beat you, held for your approval.
Choose Indexly if you want
- SEO and AI search in one subscription
- Several countries on the entry plan
- Social and forum agents
Choose Proofsource if you want
- All four main engines by default
- Intervals before alerts
- A trial you can run alone
Already using Indexly?
You do not have to choose on day one. Here is how teams run Proofsource beside Indexly and decide on their own data.
Keep Indexly running
Nothing about trying Proofsource needs you to stop Indexly. Your history and reports there stay where they are.
Bring your questions across
Export or copy the prompts you track in Indexly and add them as buyer questions in Proofsource, so both tools ask the same things.
Run both side by side
Read the two for the same days on your own domain. Where the numbers differ, Proofsource shows the answers and the pages each engine cited, so you can see why.
Keep what serves your team
Many teams keep one tool for reporting and another for fixes. Pick on your own evidence, not on a comparison page.
Proofsource or Indexly: what buyers ask
What are the best alternatives to Peec AI for tracking prompt variations and AI answer coverage?
Some AI answers to that question named Indexly. From its own pricing page: prompts tracked daily on 3 models you choose, from $99 a month. Proofsource asks each buyer question on ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews and shows, question by question and engine by engine, where your brand is named and where it is left out. We have not verified Peec AI's plans here; check its own pricing page.
What's the best way to benchmark my brand's share of AI citations against category leaders?
Ask the same buyer questions on the engines your buyers use, every day, and compare rates that carry their margin of error. Indexly tracks prompts daily on the 3 models you pick and adds citation gap analysis. Proofsource names who is cited instead of you on each question and puts a 95% interval on each rate, so a gap to the leader is a measured difference.
How much does Indexly cost?
Its pricing page lists Starter at $99, Growth at $299 and Scale at $499 a month billed monthly, with 17% off for annual billing and custom plans on request.
Does Indexly have a free trial?
Indexly's pricing page lists its paid plans. Proofsource's trial: 100 answers. 25 Prompts/Question. Top AI engines. Free. No card.
Where each fact about Indexly comes from
- Indexly pricing, read Oct 5, 2026.
- Indexly homepage, read Oct 5, 2026.
Vendors change their pages. If a Indexly fact here no longer matches their site, tell us through the contact page and we will correct it.
Your own trial settles this faster than any comparison page.
100 answers. 25 Prompts/Question. Top AI engines. Free. No card, and the report is about your domain: which buyer questions name you, who gets named instead, and what to fix.